Workplace Compensation Trap: Fairness

A very well-known culture survey (not Choose People’s) asks team members to assess the following statement: I am paid fairly.

Be careful what you assess.

The term “fair” exists in comparison. In comparison to

- my co-workers

- my friends

- hearsay regarding what other organizations in this industry pay

- what I’d hoped I would be making by the time I turned X age

This is a slippery mental chute to send your team down.

Instead consider the following to create a healthy culture context around compensation in your organization:

  • You should easily be able to speak to why someone is compensated more or less than someone else on your team.
  • Team members will share their compensation with one another. Do not attempt to discourage sharing of compensation.  That’s weird, controlling and indicates you have something to hide and cannot speak to #1.
  • Compensation doesn’t even rank in the Top 8 Factors for having team members feel good about coming to work. Your efforts to recruit and retain top talent and build a thriving workplace culture are often better spent elsewhere.  Of all the organizations we’ve worked with over our many years of doing this work – there have been only two companies where we included raises in our culture recommendations.  Team members were leaving for 50 cents more and it simply didn’t make economic sense with the cost of turnover.
  • Rather than have team members questioning and evaluating if they’re being paid fairly -consider asking, “Overall, are you content with your compensation commensurate (in proportion) to your contribution to the organization?” Please note – unlike the Choose People Culture Audit this is not a research-based statistically validated survey question, rather it's a different approach to uncovering your team’s perception of their compensation.

If you want more guidance around compensation, check out Chapter 14 in Culture Works - How to Crack the Compensation Code. Kris Boesch touches on how to “Compensate for Value and Versatility.”  Other topics covered in this chapter include:

  • Bandwidth Compensation to Value Your Best Producers
  • Decide How Compensation is Determined
  • Avoid Extortion and Support Those Who Want to Leave
  • Define How Raises are Determined
  • Choose Compensation Package Options
  • Beware of Profit Sharing, Bonuses, Commissions and Incentives

Another Culture Tip you may appreciate: How to Mitigate Money Stories.

Culture Works Book

With Culture Works in your hands you’ll know exactly how, and what to do to manage your workplace culture.
No other workplace culture book empowers you to take on workplace challenges like the researched and proven 8 Critical Factors found in Culture Works.
Paper airplane for newsletter sign up

Get actionable insights in your inbox.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.